← All Neck Pain articles

srini.presentsfor curious grown-ups

THE HUMAN MACHINE · NECK PAIN SERIES · 03

How Can a Problem in My Neck Make My Fingers Tingle?

An ache near the shoulder. Pins and needles in the thumb. Follow one arm to see why the clinician starts at the neck and checks the wrist too.

Pins and needlesNeck or wrist?When to get help
Zappy
following the tingle
Prof. Bolt
tracing the nerve

ABOUT 7 MINUTES

01

The thumb that buzzed at breakfast

Imagine you’re pouring the morning coffee. Someone calls from behind you. You turn your head, and a familiar ache runs from your right shoulder down the arm. A moment later, your thumb feels as though it’s buzzing against the cup.

You set the cup down and rub your thumb. There’s no cut or swelling to point to. The sensation fades, then comes back later while you’re at your desk.

The short answer. A nerve can become irritated where it leaves the neck and cause pins and needles farther down, even in the fingers. Clinicians call this cervical radiculopathy when a nerve root in the neck is affected. Tingling can also start with a nerve problem closer to the hand. [1] [2]

The coffee-cup scene is imagined. We’ll follow the same arm from breakfast to the examination room and see which details help locate the trouble.

ZappyIf it’s my thumb that tingles, why look at my neck?

Prof. BoltBecause the signal from your thumb travels through nerves that connect back to your neck.

02

Follow the signal upstream

When you pick up your cup, nerves carry information about touch and temperature from the hand towards the spinal cord. Nerves also carry signals in the other direction to the muscles that move the arm and hand. The short section near the spine is called a nerve root. [1]

Think of the root as a junction on the route from the hand to the spine. Changes around a disc or a nearby joint can leave less room at that junction. Inflammation can also irritate a root. The result may be pain down the arm, tingling, reduced feeling or weakness in muscles supplied by the affected root. [1] [2]

Back at the breakfast table, the buzz was real even though the thumb looked normal. In our example, the timing of that buzz is the clue: it appeared alongside an ache travelling down the arm when the head turned. That’s worth describing to the clinician. Some people with an irritated root have little neck pain, so the whole pattern matters. [1] [2]

03

The thumb gives a clue. So does the wrist.

You point to the thumb. Clinicians learn maps that show where symptoms from different nerve roots may be felt. The thumb and thumb-side forearm can fit the C6 nerve root pattern. These maps overlap, and people’s symptoms can extend beyond the textbook boundaries. [3]

Now imagine the same thumb tingling mainly when you wake at night, with pins and needles in the index and middle fingers too. Shaking the hand brings temporary relief. That history can point towards carpal tunnel syndrome, where the median nerve is compressed at the wrist. There’s enough overlap that both stories could begin with the sentence “My thumb tingles.” [3] [4]

At the visit, say where the sensation starts and where it ends. Mention whether it changes when you move your neck, or wakes you when your wrist has been bent. A description of what happened over a whole day can add more than the name of one finger. [1] [4]

ZappyDoes the thumb have its own postcode?

Prof. BoltIt has an address. More than one nerve problem can send symptoms there.

04

Why the doctor taps your elbow

You come in expecting someone to press on your neck. Instead, the clinician asks you to bend your elbow against resistance, checks how light touch feels on both sides, then taps near the elbow with a small reflex hammer.

Each check answers a different question. Is the skin less sensitive on part of the hand or forearm? Can the muscles produce the same force on both sides? Does a tendon reflex look different on the affected side? A reflex is the brief, automatic muscle response you see after the tap. Changes in sensation, strength and reflexes can help locate a nerve problem. [1] [3]

The clinician checks the wrist and hand too. If the story and examination point in different directions, nerve conduction studies and electromyography may help distinguish a problem at the wrist from a nerve-root problem. These tests are selected for the question the examination leaves open. [1] [3]

THE DEEP DIVEWhat the scan and the studies can tell you
05

Will an MRI settle it?

An MRI can show the discs, nerve roots and surrounding structures. The clinician looks for a finding that fits the side, level and symptoms. An abnormal-looking disc can also appear in someone with no symptoms, so the picture needs to make sense alongside the examination. [1] [3]

Suppose the tingling from breakfast is intermittent, your strength is stable and there are no warning signs. The clinician may begin with an examination and follow-up. If symptoms persist, or a deficit such as weakness progresses, imaging may help guide the next decision. How soon that happens depends on the findings. [2] [3]

Here’s a question you can take into the appointment. “If the scan shows a disc bulge, what would tell us it explains my right thumb?” The answer should come back to your arm, your symptoms and what the clinician found when they examined you.

ZappySo a scan is another clue?

Prof. BoltYes. The picture is most useful when it fits the story and the examination.

06

What improved in a treatment trial?

Many people with cervical radiculopathy improve over time, and initial care is often without surgery. A clinician can discuss activity, physiotherapy or other options based on the examination and how much symptoms affect daily life. [1] [2]

In a randomised trial published in the BMJ, researchers enrolled 205 patients with recent-onset cervical radiculopathy. They compared physiotherapy with home exercises, a short period of collar use and rest, and a group advised to carry on with daily activities as much as possible. [5]

By six weeks, the two active-treatment groups had about 12 extra points of improvement in arm pain on a 100-point scale compared with the third group. At six months, pain scores were similar across groups. The trial measured pain and disability in people with recent-onset radiculopathy. It gives little guidance on when an individual’s thumb tingling will stop. [5]

07

What to tell the clinician

The next time you pick up the cup, notice where the sensation goes. You can write down three things before the visit: which side and fingers, what brings it on, and what you can do with the hand. “Right thumb and thumb-side forearm, comes with an ache when I turn my head, and I can still hold a cup” gives the clinician a clear starting point. [1] [3]

Mention any tasks that have become harder. A heavier kettle may hurt to lift. A hand that has started to give way while holding a familiar cup is a different detail and deserves prompt attention. Tell the clinician if you’ve started dropping things, if buttons suddenly feel fiddly, or if you’ve noticed any change in how you walk. [2]

Arrange an assessment if the tingling is new, keeps returning or stays with you. You can bring your notes even if the hand feels completely normal during the appointment. [2]

08

When the coffee cup can wait

In the opening scene the cup stays in your hand and the pins and needles come and go. Suppose that changes. You now struggle to hold it, your hands are newly clumsy, or you feel unsteady on the walk from the kitchen. Those changes can affect how urgently you need to be seen. [2]

Seek urgent medical assessment for new or worsening arm or hand weakness, new clumsiness, trouble with balance or walking, or new bladder or bowel control changes alongside neck or limb symptoms. These can point to a problem involving the spinal cord. [2]

At the end of our imagined visit, you can tell the difference between the symptom you came in with and the changes that would make you seek help sooner. You also know why the clinician checked both ends of the route, from your neck to your hand.

ZappySo I can stop rubbing my thumb and start describing what happened?

Prof. BoltExactly. Where it began, where it went, and whether the cup still feels steady.

Prof. Bolt’s verdict

A problem at the neck can make your fingers tingle. An irritated nerve at the wrist can do it too. The best clues are where the feeling travels, what brings it on and what the examination shows.

Before your visit, note which fingers tingle, what brings it on and whether the hand is harder to use.

Fridge-door cheat sheet

  • Follow the tingle from where it starts to where it ends.
  • The thumb can be a clue to either a neck or a wrist problem.
  • Get new, recurrent or persistent symptoms assessed.
  • Seek urgent assessment for new weakness, clumsy hands, walking difficulty or bladder or bowel changes with neck or limb symptoms.

The evidence file

General information only. The coffee-cup story and dialogue are fictional. The treatment trial measured arm and neck pain and disability. Its group averages do not predict an individual’s recovery.

  1. AAOS OrthoInfo · Cervical Radiculopathy. Patient guide covering nerve roots, symptoms, examination and treatment.
  2. NHS inform · Cervical radiculopathy. Public health guidance on symptoms, usual recovery and urgent warning signs.
  3. American Family Physician · Nonoperative Management of Cervical Radiculopathy. Clinical review, 2016. Typical nerve-root patterns, examination, MRI and nerve tests.
  4. AAOS OrthoInfo · Carpal Tunnel Syndrome. Patient guide on median nerve compression and typical nighttime symptoms.
  5. Kuijper and colleagues · Cervical collar or physiotherapy versus wait and see. Randomised trial, 2009. Compared three care approaches in recent-onset cervical radiculopathy.
Follow @srini.presentsYouTube · Instagram · Facebook
Read more: srinipresents.com